Jump to content


Photo

1.2.8 altering course within minimum range


  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 franklin1k

franklin1k

    Private

  • ODGW Members
  • 3 posts

Posted Yesterday, 08:22 PM

Can some one give me an example of this rule?



#2 Jim O'Neil

Jim O'Neil

    Captain

  • ODGW Members
  • 333 posts
  • LocationSE Arizona, Sierra Vista/ Ft Huachuca area

Posted Today, 01:03 PM

I think it is fairly obvious that collisions between surface ships are undesirable. So if your plotted course brings you within 2,000 yards of an enemy ship, you may make ONE turn of up to six points (135º), intended to avoid collision BUT that is not specified. We know many ships rammed submarines when possible, so that is also a possibility with this rule. No clue as to whether that was the intent of this rule, but I would allow it.


  • jwsleser likes this

#3 jwsleser

jwsleser

    Corporal

  • ODGW Members
  • 59 posts
  • LocationLeavenworth, KS

Posted Today, 05:42 PM

I agree with Jim. I also believe that intent includes the ability to quickly counter any enemy aggressive moves that could place a ship at a disadvantage. I feel the intent stated in the rule supports this. (The use of plotted movement, as detailed in  Section 1.2.5, simulates normal combat distances as it takes  considerable time to determine when another ship is altering  course. At minimum range, however, this becomes apparent  more quickly, enabling captains to make last minute changes to avoid collisions and avoid closing more than intended.)

 

To clarify, both sides have plotted movement. During the physical movement of the ships, they come closer than 2,000 yards (20cm) with movement remaining. One (or both) ships can CHANGE the remaining part of their plotted movement to include up to a six-point turn (135º as Jim stated). I assume that once the turn is made, any remaining movement must be straight ahead. 

 

The submarine example (intentional ram) is an interesting case. I assume that once the ship and boat are within 2000 yards, the boat captain can decide to made the elective turn to avoid. The ship captain can then decide whether to execute its elective turn to continue to attempt to ram. If the collision conditions are still met after the maneuvers, Intentional Ram under Rule 1.3.1 is used  with the boat getting a +1 for Evading Submarine. 

 

What needs clarification is whether the ability to modify the already plotted course continues in subsequent turns if the ships remain within 2000 yards. I would say yes. E.g. both ships are within 2000 yards of each other when they plot their next turn. One ship decides to be aggressive and decides to attempt to cross either forward or aft of the other ship which keeps the two ships within 2000 yards. Once the enemy ship sees the maneuver, it can opt to turn instead of following its written orders as the captain can quickly perceive the maneuver. I feel this is supported by the statement in the rule After a ship moves more than 2ooo yds from an opposing ship, her course is again restricted to her movement plot.

 

Just my humble opinion. 

 

v/r  Jeff



#4 franklin1k

franklin1k

    Private

  • ODGW Members
  • 3 posts

Posted Today, 06:00 PM

Thanks for the replies.

I read it as a ship may make ONE turn starboard or port one hex side if I came within a spotted ship within a range of 2,00 yards.  Friendly or enemy.  Is this wrong?






1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users