Jump to content


Photo

Alternate Cape Matapan


  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 Jim O'Neil

Jim O'Neil

    Captain

  • ODGW Members
  • 335 posts
  • LocationSE Arizona, Sierra Vista/ Ft Huachuca area

Posted 30 October 2026 - 09:40 PM

We are working on the next part of the Mediterranean War and based on a request to research the Battle of Cape Matapan and see if the Italian cruiser Task Force [Built around Bolzano, Trento & Trieste, Ascari, Carabiniere, Corazziere] would have done better in this battle. Why? I asked; “Well they had more torpedoes” I was told.  The answer is: not a bit of you aren’t alert.  The Italian force [historically Zara, Fiume and four destroyers] was quite well equipped with torpedoes.  

 
The issue was that when the Italian lookout reported ships closing from the Northeast at 2220 hrs., Ammiraglio di divisione Carlo Cattaneo, who seems to have been a decent commander, courageous and thoughtful, did nothing when he could have ordered battle stations and taken actions to be sure of whether the closing ships were friend or foe. That action alone could have significantly altered history.
 
The battleships Warspite, Valiant, and  Barham, accompanied by the aircraft carrier Formidable (In front of Barham) in the battle line,  were able to close to 3,800 yards (3,500 m) historically  – point blank range for battleship guns – at which point they opened fire at 2228 hrs.. There were nine RN destroyers: HMS Greyhound, Griffin, Jervis, Janus, Mohawk, Nubian, Hotspur and Havock and HMAS Stuart accompanying the battleships, but were held back behind the battle line. 
 
So what happens if the lookout's report of ships closing at 2220 is acted upon? Warspite turned and opened fire at 2228 Hrs. In the preceding seven minutes, what could the Italians have done? Even if we assume that they were not at battle stations (which would have been dumb considering), they could have been there in three minutes. Each of the four Italian Destroyers  had two triple torpedo mounts. At 4,000 yards, it shouldn’t have been too hard to get a hit or two on the old RN battleships or the carrier (which did pull out of line quickly when it realized what was going on). For those who aren’t so conversant, the old British Battleships didn’t take torpedoes very gracefully, compared to newer designs. HMS Barham was later sunk by two or so torpedoes, granted she wasn’t at battle stations.
 
Play it out , I'd like to know how it ends up.
 
For What it’s Worth, Ammiraglio di divisione Carlo Cattaneo intended  to send two DDs to assist POLA, not the whole division, But Admiral Iachino ordered him to take the whole division. Again a questionable decision.


#2 JAHinson

JAHinson

    Private

  • ODGW Members
  • 13 posts
  • LocationLeavenworth, KS

Posted 10 November 2026 - 02:44 PM

Thanks for the idea.  I played it out a couple of times solo with stand in ships which I won't bother showing pictures of since I have no Italian or British Med ships. 

 

In the first I Allowed Cattaneo a different set up from historical, so he led with his destroyers in the van.  I had Cunningham 'come in dumb' holding his destroyers back behind the battleline instead of in a screening position. The Italians were able to position for and launch a torpedo attack attempt.  In my play-through it was unsuccessful (unlucky rolls) and avoided by the British line who then decimated the Italian squadron.  In the second I allowed Cattaneo the same lead with his destroyers set up.  I had Cunningham use his destroyers as a screen and aggressively engage the Italian screen.  In this case I had a British destroyer torpedoed (lucky roll, bulkhead and fire result) in the scrimmage of the light forces, the Italian destroyers never got in range of the British line, and the Italian force was again decimated.  My Cunningham was more patient in the second play through perhaps than the one who may have been pushing to find the Italian BB somewhere further west.

 

British night fighting and radar don't really allow for disengagement so it's a fight to the death.  I tried smoke and creative maneuvering in the second play through but to no avail.

The REGIA MARINA ITALIANA DARK ACQUISITION table is really bad, LOL, so the British will absolutely have the initiative and decide the range at which the action begins.  I found it interesting to ponder what decisions Cunningham might make with a perceived destroyer threat and how he might change his dispositions on closing depending upon what he observed.

 

I found this a good read in preparation for playing as I didn't know a lot about the battle: https://regiamarina....le-of-matapan/ 



#3 Jim O'Neil

Jim O'Neil

    Captain

  • ODGW Members
  • 335 posts
  • LocationSE Arizona, Sierra Vista/ Ft Huachuca area

Posted 12 November 2026 - 01:25 PM

Well, I granted the Italians the actual spotting success they historically had. I would also point out that if the Italians turn away with smoke, the British cannot engae with radar, as they have no blind fire capability. The DDs can pursue of course, but will suffer from the Italians cruisers gunfire under illumination. The Italians keep making smoke until well away from the big ships. The RN  DDs will have some trouble catching up and getting far enough in front to use torpedoes.


  • JAHinson likes this

#4 JAHinson

JAHinson

    Private

  • ODGW Members
  • 13 posts
  • LocationLeavenworth, KS

Posted 12 November 2026 - 02:45 PM

Yes, I did start at 2200 to see what might happen with different set ups on the approach and to try and get more practice with the night rules rather than start at 2220.  I probably should have mentioned that.


  • Jim O'Neil likes this




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users